The Null Institute / Publications

Verification Pilots

Focused, independently checkable studies of public claims, published research, datasets and alternative explanations. Each report describes what was tested, what the evidence supports, and what remains unresolved. A pilot is not a claim of peer review.

13 publications

Verification pilot

Dunning–Kruger Reanalysis: The Scale, the Baseline, and the Error Curve

Independent 151-person reanalysis confirms the skill–self-assessment error gradient. The sample-wide downward offset, unusual response scale, baseline-to-test change, and rank reference limit claims about the mechanism.

Nov 18, 2026
Verification pilot

Small SBA Loans Fell 35%. Outside Five Lenders, Their Share Rose

We independently analysed 403,644 SBA 7(a) loan records. Approvals under $50,000 fell 34.7% in FY2026, but five lender names account for 88.2% of the net decline; the small-loan share actually rose among other lenders.

Nov 13, 2026
Verification pilot

AI Tutors and the Human Work Behind 94,385 Checks

An independent audit of Google and Eedi's 1,179-pupil trial: immediate maths gains, no detected Star Maths advantage, and 94,385 mandatory human checks. The trial cannot yet establish staffing savings.

Nov 13, 2026
Verification pilot

Friday the 13th: We Rechecked the Study Behind the Accident Scare

We reanalysed all 61 observations behind a famous Friday-the-13th accident study. Hospital admissions rose in six matched date pairs, but the statistical conclusion changes with the test. Motorway traffic was lower, while shopping was not.

Nov 13, 2026
Verification pilot

A Sixfold Birthday-Week Disease Signal Under Audit: Statistical Inconsistencies and Automatically Generated Birth Dates

An independent audit of a reported sixfold HFMD birthday-week effect finds a nonreproducible chi-square statistic, regression-model inconsistencies, and historical evidence that China's disease-reporting system generated birth dates from ages. The mechanism's role in Yunnan remains unproven.

Nov 6, 2026
Verification pilot

Can We Rank Countries by Smiling? An Audit of 125 Geographies and 24 Source Families

A secondary synthesis of 24 smiling-data source families across 125 geographies. We audit cross-study concordance, model weighting and the limits of claims about happiness.

Oct 31, 2026
Verification pilot

Inconsistent Denominators and Image-Coordinate Frames in a 28-Country Visual Communication Dataset

An independent, source-verifiable reanalysis of 79,500 political images finds a numerator–denominator mismatch in published country percentages and incompatible facial coordinates and image frames. Includes reproduced logistic models, methodological limitations and open code.

Oct 31, 2026
Verification pilot

A Likely Double Count in a Published Water–Mortality Study

An independent audit of NHANES 1999–2014 finds that the water-source distributions reported by Zhou et al. (2022) closely match a reconstruction with likely double counting of drinking water after 2005. The mortality implications remain unresolved.

Oct 16, 2026
Verification pilot

How Often Does One Blood Pressure Reading Change the Category? NHANES 2021–2023

In a survey-weighted NHANES 2021–2023 reanalysis, 16.4% of adults changed US blood-pressure category between the first reading and the average of three. These are within-visit category changes, not diagnostic errors.

Oct 13, 2026
Verification pilot

What Does the Beverage Hydration Index Actually Measure?

The Beverage Hydration Index is reproducible. But does less urine after a drink really mean better hydration? A construct-validity, outcome, and claim-drift audit.

Oct 4, 2026
Verification pilot

Does Killing Oral Bacteria Actually Make the Mouth Healthier?

Chlorhexidine kills oral bacteria and reduces plaque. But does suppressing the microbiome actually improve health? A falsification-oriented evidence review.

Oct 3, 2026
Verification pilot

Repeatability Is Not Transportability: What Makes a Standardized Glucose Challenge Informative?

A harmonized reanalysis of CGMacros and Stanford/Hall suggests that a standardized glucose challenge can be repeatable without being useful for cross-meal personalization. Food & You further weakens the idea that larger glucose excursions are automatically more informative.

Oct 2, 2026